MAIL

ACTUAL LETTERS
FROM
ACTUAL READERS





Former P-I Reporter Defends Media Coverage of Boeing

It is good to see another journalistic voice in Seattle, especially one concerned with raking muck. May you prosper.

Your opening effort on Boeing's environmental problems (Free Press , April 1993) touched on an unusually sensitive issue for the company and the region. It has always seemed odd that a state so environmentally conscious as Washington has paid so little attention to pollution on the scale practiced by Boeing.

No doubt some of that is a matter of perspective: Boeing is so big that sometimes its specific sins get smothered by the background noise. You are also correct that the company's size and regional concentration give its public relations and lobbying arms unusual local clout. It can be tough sometimes getting through the smoke.

On your related media criticism, two points ought to be made - one small and the other more substantive. My articles in the P-I on Boeing's environmental record were written two - not 10 - years ago. More important, I think local news coverage of Boeing has changed considerably since [former Seattle Times reporter] Doug Underwood's critical - and justified - Columbia Journalism Review article in 1988.

When I came to the P-I in 1990, the paper clearly had decided to keep a hard light on the company. Since then, the P-I has run articles detailing Boeing's trafficking in unauthorized classified documents, problems with shoddy military hardware and faulty commercial-jet parts, alleged racism at its plants, its billion-dollar state tax loopholes, cover-up of cancer problems at its secret missile-site test program and nearly a dozen front-page stories on the company's local and national environmental problems.

The work was done by reporters both in Seattle and Washington, DC, and involved a substantial commitment of time and money on the paper's part - not to mention a willingness to weather Boeing's unhappiness.

During the same period, the Seattle Times focused on several other critical problems and did especially strong work on equipment flaws that may be linked to crashes of Boeing's commercial jets.

This is a windy way of saying that local media critics - named and unnamed - may not be paying very close attention. Over the last couple of years, Boeing has been one of the most aggressively covered companies in the country and most of that work has been done by the local press. I hope your paper keeps contributing to the effort.

Bill Richards
Bainbridge Island, WA



Editor's note:
Now a Northwest correspondent for the Wall Street Journal , Bill Richards occasionally writes about Boeing.




'Hate Mongering' John Carlson Unworthy of Consideration

An article in your April issue mentioned that local political columnist and media commentator John Carlson, after lunching with Seattle Times publisher/CEO Frank Blethen and editorial page editor Mindy Cameron, will now be writing columns for the Times.

Formerly the publisher of the Washington Spectator, Carlson says that publication (not to be confused with Seattle University's student newspaper, The Spectator ) "was a campus response to the UW Daily."

No, the Spectator was a knee-jerk response by dedicated right-wingers, many of whom boasted no affiliation with the UW campus. Funds for the paper were provided in part by nationally influential, conservative think tanks, like the Heritage Foundation based in Washington, DC. The sophomoric newspaper gleefully published, among other liberal-bashing articles, snide asides about feminists, blacks, Jews and others. Gays were openly referred to as sodomists, child molesters - or worse - as AIDS spreaders.

Has Mindy Cameron or Frank Blethen or the editors of the Free Press ever bothered to read a copy of the Spectator ?

According to the Free Press , "most of us realize that all debates are enhanced by the interjection of all points of view." Differing points of view must be tolerated in our society, sure. But John Carlson's thinly veiled hate mongering doesn't encourage reasonable debate.

Alan Neff
Seattle




Ex-Weekly Employee Tells of 'Arbitrary' Layoffs

I was pleased to see in your pages a bit of an expose on the Seattle Weekly's sometimes questionable management practices. You may be aware that, in addition to the more recent layoffs, five employees were laid off a year ago, including the chief proofreader (me), the staff photographer, the assistant managing editor (who had been closely associated with David Brewster and had worked at the paper about seven years), an executive assistant to Mr. Brewster and an employee in the accounting or business department.

All were women of child-bearing age, and one was pregnant at the time of her dismissal.

Employees seem to be fired with arbitrary abandon at times; art directors at the Weekly appear to be particularly vulnerable to the whims of the publisher and managing editor, who seem to feel that it is the appearance of the art director's work that makes or breaks their publication. As soon as they hire a new art director, whose work they are excited about, that person goes on trial - and would be well advised to keep other job possibilities in mind.

I worked at the Weekly for almost three years and watched some of my favorite co-workers get the ax. I also watched, not altogether passively, as my own job was gradually taken away from me and the proofreading department was dismantled. It is my understanding that, currently, only a portion of the classified section of the paper is proofread. Other copy is sent directly from the (lone) copy editor to the typesetting department.

I am not sorry that I no longer work at the Weekly. I am somewhat sympathetic to the paper's financial dilemmas and miscalculations. I am not sympathetic to unfair hiring and firing practices, and I don't miss belonging to any kind of "happy family" that boots its members arbitrarily.

Julie Carter
Seattle


[Home] [This Issue's Directory] [WFP Index] [WFP Back Issues] [E-Mail WFP]

Contents on this page were published in the May, 1993 edition of the Washington Free Press.
WFP, 1463 E. Republican #178, Seattle, WA -USA, 98112. -- WAfreepress@gmail.com
Copyright © 1993 WFP Collective, Inc.